The Hiring Decision You Shouldn't Leave to AI

Published By
Tom Millington
Nov 12, 2026
AI is becoming part of how businesses recruit, and I can understand why.
When you're managing projects, dealing with workforce shortages and trying to find time to interview candidates, anything that makes recruitment more efficient is worth considering.
But there's one part of the process I'd be careful about handing over to AI: deciding whether someone can actually do the job.
Think about a Project Manager whose CV says they've delivered a $50 million project. On paper, that might look like exactly the experience you're looking for.
But there's a big difference between someone who managed that project from start to finish and someone who was responsible for one part of it.
That's not always something you'll pick up from a CV, even with AI helping you assess applications.
And it's why I think businesses need to be careful about where they draw the line between using technology to support recruitment and relying on it to make hiring decisions.
On this Week's Toolbox, here are three things I'd consider before introducing more AI into your hiring process.
1. Look beyond what's written on the CV
AI can help you review applications and identify candidates whose experience appears to match your requirements.
But a well-written CV doesn't always tell you what someone was personally responsible for.
When I'm speaking with candidates, I want to understand the decisions they've made, the problems they've dealt with and what they actually contributed to a project.
One question I would suggest asking is:
Tell me about a challenging situation on a project, what you personally did to resolve it and what happened afterwards.
The answer gives you a much clearer picture of someone's experience than simply knowing the size of the projects they've worked on.
2. Don't automate away the conversation candidates need
An AI interview might save your hiring manager time, but one thing I talk about regularly is the importance of treating the first interview as an alignment discussion, not just an assessment.
You're trying to understand whether the candidate has the experience and capability your business needs. But the candidate is also trying to understand whether the opportunity aligns with what they're looking for.
That means having a genuine conversation about the role, the projects, the team, the expectations and what both sides want from the move.
An AI interview might help you collect answers to a set of questions, but it can also limit the opportunity for candidates to ask their own questions, explore the role properly and get a feel for the people they'd be working with.
That's worth considering, particularly when you're approaching experienced people who might already be in good positions.
If you're considering AI interviews, think about whether candidates will still have a proper opportunity to ask questions and understand the business.
And if AI is part of your interview process, be upfront about it.
Recruitment needs to work for both sides, not just make things more convenient for the employer.
3. Make sure a person is still accountable for the decision
There's nothing wrong with using AI to help organise applications, prepare interview notes or reduce administrative work.
But there's a difference between using AI to support a decision and relying on it to make one.
When you're hiring someone to manage subcontractors, lead a site team or take responsibility for project delivery, you need confidence in their judgement and capability.
And someone within your business needs to be accountable for assessing that.
AI can help you identify people worth considering. It shouldn't replace the judgement needed to decide whether they're right for your business.
Here's my challenge this week: Look at where AI sits in your current recruitment process and ask yourself whether it's helping you make better decisions or simply helping you make them faster.
Those aren't necessarily the same thing.
There are parts of recruitment where efficiency makes a real difference, but there are also conversations that are worth taking the time to have.
And knowing the difference is becoming increasingly important.
Want to explore another side of this discussion?
In the latest Leader Scout episode, Are Employers Taking AI Too Far? Listen here, I look at what happens when candidates start using AI to respond to AI interviewers, and whether employers should be surprised when that happens.
If you're a business owner or hiring manager considering how technology fits into your recruitment strategy, or you're questioning whether your current process is helping you identify the right people, feel free to reach out.
Share on social media







